Democracy and Other Problems

Share this post

Is Freedom Good Only if You Use it Well?

www.shadihamid.net

Discover more from Democracy and Other Problems

A newsletter committed to exploring how and why democracy produces "bad" outcomes—and what to do about it.
Over 1,000 subscribers
Continue reading
Sign in

Is Freedom Good Only if You Use it Well?

The "worthiness" of an idea, a goal, a hope is an inherently subjective matter.

Shadi Hamid
Nov 14, 2022
3
Share this post

Is Freedom Good Only if You Use it Well?

www.shadihamid.net
Share
black and red round ornament

In his introduction to James Salter’s A Sport and a Pastime, the American novelist Reynolds Price notes that “winning a freedom and then proceeding to employ it worthily are two decidedly different matters.”

To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

I was struck when I came across this sentence. I am reading A Sport and a Pastime for the first time (after having declared, perhaps in overwrought fashion, that Salter’s Light Years was the greatest novel of the 20th century). The overarching question that both haunts and animates my book on “the problem of democracy” is a version of Price’s distinction between having something and then using it well.

What does it mean to employ freedom—or, for that matter, democracy—worthily? The word “worthily” makes me a bit nervous. One definition is “having adequate or great merit, character, or value.” Who decides whether something is of merit or value? And once we figure out who decides, then it raises the question of how. How does one go about casting judgment on an inherently subjective matter?

I wrote recently on Twitter the following (and was ratio-ed):

Twitter avatar for @shadihamid
Shadi Hamid @shadihamid
As time passes, I feel increasingly uncomfortable making judgments about what constitutes a good or bad democratic outcome. Since we, as Americans, no longer agree on what constitutes "goodness," there's no way to definitely render judgment on a democratic outcome we don't like.
3:21 AM ∙ Nov 8, 2022
104Likes11Retweets

The same can be said for using something—anything—worthily. There are two ways to make such a judgment. The first is for it to be a personal verdict. I can decide whether something I do, or something someone else does, is worthy. The second is for someone else to render judgment on what I do, but presumably their judgment has no binding authority or effect on me.

In divided societies, where we no longer agree on foundational questions, this creates something of a tricky dilemma. If we no longer agree on foundational questions—did we ever?—any attempt at rendering judgment or determining what is “worthy” is immediately suspect.

Share

3
Share this post

Is Freedom Good Only if You Use it Well?

www.shadihamid.net
Share
Previous
Next
Comments
Top
New
Community

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Shadi Hamid
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing